10:30 a.m. 20A04-1112-CR-699. Allen Superior Court Courtroom 1. James Young appeals his conviction for Class D felony domestic
battery and Class D felony strangulation following a jury trial. Young’s wife, the victim, did not testify at
trial, but two firefighters and a police officer who had spoken with her at or near the time of the incidents involved were
allowed to testify concerning the substance of the statements she made to them.
Young presents the following issues for review on appeal: (1) whether the firefighters’ and police officer’s
testimony regarding the victim’s statement to them was a violation of the Confrontation Clause within the Sixth Amendment
of the Constitution of the United States or permissible questioning during an ongoing emergency; (2) whether the trial court
abused its discretion in concluding that the victim’s statement to the police officer, more than 45 minutes after the
incidents, was an excited utterance; and (3) whether there was sufficient evidence to prove that Young committed the offenses
in a child’s physical presence so as to elevate the domestic battery offense to a Class D felony.
Jack, I was only responding to bill's comment of tying everybody in government together. I agree with you though, it takes one bad apple to ruin the bunch.. As in any profession. What's truly unfair is when somebody violates someone's trust and takes complete advantage of someone
John’s comment is unfair. The majority of attorneys can be trusted. Unfortunately, all it takes is one greedy, unscrupulous, immoral attorney to jade the public.
In regards to bill's comment about trusting the cover meant. We can trust them about as much as we can trust attorneys'.
This is disturbing to learn...
Yikes!