January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsBankruptcy filings have increased so much in Indiana that some U.S. trustees handling Chapter 7 proceedings may want to add
an extra session each month to hear new cases.Attorneys statewide are seeing more clients from an uptick in filings, and as
a result are not surprised to hear that federal filings across the country surged 38 percent in 2007. Nor are they surprised
that Indiana ranked fourth highest in the nation overall and top in the country for the number of...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonThe Morgan County Courthouse is closed today as a result of damage sustained by high winds from Tuesday's storm, and a courthouse
disaster plan mandated by a new state rule has been kicked into gear for the first time.North and west sides of the courthouse's
roof were heavily damaged in the storm. One half of the roof has been blown completely off, including the tresses and some
of the brick wall it was attached to, said Jeff Neal, director of Morgan...
More
January 1, 2008
IL StaffBills about the discharge of long-term inmates, judges' pensions, and various provisions concerning courts were among the
remaining 33 bills sent to the governor's office that were signed into law yesterday.SEA 258 deals with the discharge of long-term
inmates, GPS monitoring of certain sex offenders, and the conditions for probation or parole of a sex offender.SEA 329 allows
full-time magistrates on or after July 1, 2010, to become participants in the judges' 1985 benefit system; increases the court
administration fee from...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonOvernight visits must take place overnight in order to be used in a claim for parenting time credit under the child support
guidelines, ruled the Indiana Supreme Court Aug. 19. In Marla K. Young v. Timothy S. Young, No. 09S05-0803-CV-136, the
high court addressed whether evening visits could be credited as overnight visits when calculating child support. Timothy
Young was awarded 104 overnights, including 52 which were for two additional evenings per week he spent with their kids. But
evening visits shouldn't...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsA city's law prohibiting registered sex offenders from visiting parks or recreation areas is likely on its way to the Indiana
Court of Appeals in what a civil liberties attorney said could be the first appellate case of its kind in the country.A ruling
from Hendricks Superior Judge Robert Freeze March 14 upholds a Plainfield ban of sex offenders in parks and recreational areas,
finding the six-year-old local ordinance constitutional and not in violation of any guideposts established by the state...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsThe Supreme Court of the United States will hear its second case this term from Indiana on March 26, considering whether
a defendant found competent to stand trial should also be allowed to represent himself.Justices granted certiorari in December
for Indiana v. Edwards, No. 07-208, which follows an Indiana Supreme Court ruling in May 2007. The case stems from a July
1999 downtown Indianapolis incident in which Ahmad Edwards was caught on surveillance tape stealing shoes. He ultimately shot
at police multiple...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsThe Indiana Supreme Court has accepted five new cases. At its weekly conference Aug. 28, justices granted transfer in
two civil cases, two criminal cases, and a tax court case. • Brenda and Darren Wagner v. Bobbi Yates, et al., No.
22A01-0710-CV-474: An underinsured motorist policy case from Floyd County. The Court of Appeals in April affirmed the
lower court's granting of a motion for summary judgment in favor of American Standard Insurance Company of Wisconsin,
the Wagners' automobile insurer. The court ruled that American Standard can set...
More
January 1, 2008
IL StaffThe United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana has published the amendments made to its Local Rules.
After considering the proposed amendments and comments received, changes have been made to several rules including Rule 5.1
- General Format of Documents Presented for Filing, Rule 56.1 - Summary Judgment Procedure, and Rule II - Discipline Imposed
by Other Courts. To view all of the changes, visit the District Court's Web site and click on the "Notice of Amendments to...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsThe Supreme Court of the United States has defined money laundering and tossed out the convictions of an East Chicago man
in a split decision today.The high court ruled on U.S. v. Efrain Santos, et al., No. 06-1005, which involved a money-laundering
ring in East Chicago. This was one of two money-laundering cases decided by the court today; the other came in Cuellar v.
U.S., No. 06-1456, which held that mere concealment of money during a transport is not enough to support...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsThe Indiana Supreme Court made history this week.The current five justices reached a record-setting milestone Feb. 24 in
the number of days they've served together on the state's highest court. Chief Justice Randall T. Shepard and Justices Ted
Boehm, Brent Dickson, Robert Rucker, and Frank Sullivan have been together for 3,040 consecutive days, according to the Appellate
Clerk's Office.To be clear: They've been together since Justice Rucker joined the court Nov. 19, 1999.The previous record
goes back to 1985. Justices Alfred Pivarnik, Dixon...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsA day before a multi-million dollar class action suit was supposed to go to trial, attorneys reached a settlement in the state
employees' equal pay case that is expected to give every plaintiff what they asked for.The class - made up of as many as 15,000
former state employees - wanted compensation for hours they worked between 1973 and 1993 and didn't receive equal pay of fellow
workers, who had only worked 37 1/2 hours compared to their 40 hours a...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonThe Indiana Court of Appeals reversed a trial court order finding a father in contempt of court for not complying with orders
stemming from post-dissolution proceedings, ruling the father did comply with an order requiring he update his ex-wife with
documents regarding a trust for his children's education. In David L. Bartlemay v. Nancy Witt, f/k/a Nancy Bartlemay, No.
89A04-0802-CV-50, David Bartlemay appealed a 2007 trial court order that he was in contempt of court for violating previous
orders following the dissolution...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonThe Indiana General Assembly reconvened today with property tax issues consuming much of the focus of the 2008 short session.
Also receiving much attention are issues regarding sex offenders, education, and the environment. Another bill of interest
to the legal community is House Bill 1045, which introduces a courthouse preservation advisory commission and courthouse preservation
fund, and requires the commission to provide assistance for courthouse related projects. Grandparent visitation rights are
dealt with in Senate Bill 48, which allows for a...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonThe Indiana Supreme Court granted four transfers last week, though one was remanded to the state's Court of Appeals while
another came with a significant ruling about community rental restrictions.In taking the cases, justices now have a chance
to weigh in on the denial of post-conviction relief regarding a habitual offender enhancement and driving an ATV while drunk
on private property.On May 13, the high court granted transfer in State of Indiana v. Adam L. Manuwal, No. 50A05-0703-CR-182,
which asks whether the...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsThe United States is stepping up to better protect intellectual property. If there was any doubt before, it's official now
with a new law signed by President George W. Bush Oct. 13. Known as the Prioritizing Resources and Organization for Intellectual
Property Act of 2008, or PRO IP for short, the law is designed to strengthen existing copyright laws, create civil forfeiture
clauses so equipment believed to be used in an IP crime can be seized, and establish a cabinet-level position...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonA panel of Indiana Court of Appeals judges agreed that a defendant's motion to suppress evidence of a polygraph test should
have been granted by the trial court. But the judges had differing reasons for granting the reversal of the trial court, with
the majority deviating from precedent on when the right to counsel begins.In Thomas E. Caraway v. State of Indiana, No.
47A01-0709-CR-416, Thomas Caraway appealed the trial court's denial of his motion to suppress and exclude all evidence of
a...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonThe Indiana Court of Appeals reversed a trial court denial of a father's post-dissolution motion for rule to show cause why
his ex-wife shouldn't be held in contempt, and remanded for the court to enter a new order. In John L. Richardson v. Susan
E. Hansrote, No. 72A01-0706-CV-288, Richardson appealed the trial court denial, raising three issues: whether the trial
court erred when it determined he had a child-support arrearage; whether the error by the court clerk, who mistakenly applied
Richardson's child...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonThe state can't obtain title to a disputed tract of land through adverse possession because the state can't satisfy the tax
requirements in Indiana statute regarding adverse possession, the Indiana Court of Appeals ruled today in a case of first
impression.In State of Indiana v. Jeanette Serowiecki, No. 56A04-0710-CV-576, the state appealed the trial court's grant
of summary judgment in favor of Jeanette Serowiecki on the state's complaint to quiet title to an 18.6-acre tract of land
in Newton County. Serowiecki is trustee...
More
January 1, 2008
Rebecca BerfangerThe Indiana Coalition Against Domestic Violence with the assistance of pro bono attorneys in Baker & Daniels' Indianapolis
office filed notice of appeal July 22 for two non-violent contact orders issued in Marion County. The non-violent
distinction means that the respondent can have contact with the petitioner as long as it isn't violent contact. Earlier on
the same day in Indianapolis, Carl Wills allegedly killed his ex-wife, April Wills, her boyfriend, and then killed himself.
Records show that Carl had a history of...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonAttorneys who logged on this morning to the Indiana Judiciary Web site to read and print opinions were met with a challenge:
you could view, but couldn't print.The first Court of Appeals opinions of the New Year were password protected and locked
so that people accessing the online opinions were unable to print them.That was an internal, unintended glitch and the problem's
been resolved, according to Supreme Court Administrator and Appellate Clerk Kevin Smith.The opinions posted earlier this morning
disappeared temporarily...
More
January 1, 2008
IL StaffGov. Mitch Daniels appointed a new Bluffton City Court judge Feb. 28, choosing a retired car dealership owner. Robert J. Bate
succeeds Judge Gary Markley, who resigned Jan. 15.Bate was owner and president of Bob Bate Chevrolet Inc. in Ossian from 1979
to 2000. He was elected five times to serve on the Bluffton City Council between 1987 and 2007. Bate's appointment is effective
immediately.
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsThose registered sex offenders who've served their time and are no longer on probation or under court supervision cannot be
required to give blanket consent to authorities for home and computer searches, the U.S. District Court Southern District
of Indiana's chief judge ruled late afternoon on June 24.U.S. District Judge David F. Hamilton in Indianapolis struck down
a major portion of a new law set to take effect July 1, which would have required all convicted sex offenders to agree to...
More
January 1, 2008
Jennifer NelsonThe Indiana Supreme Court granted transfer May 2 to a case in which the defendant was denied post-conviction relief.
In Roderick Lee v. State of Indiana, No. 27A04-0705-PC-257, Lee filed a petition for relief asserting he received ineffective
assistance from his trial and appellate counsel. The Indiana Court of Appeals rejected Lee's arguments that his trial and
appellate counsel - the same attorney - was ineffective because the attorney failed to argue that entering judgments on Lee's
convictions of burglary and attempted robbery violate...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsThe Indiana Supreme Court has once again influenced the state's criminal sentencing scheme in a pair of rulings that are the
latest in a post-Blakely world.Justices issued decisions Thursday in Rosalio Pedraza v. State of Indiana, No. 49S04-0711-CR-516,
and Michael Sweatt v. State of Indiana, No. 49S02-0805-CR-290, which when read together offer trial courts guidance about
using a person's criminal history and enhancing penalties.The court held that double enhancements are allowed using a single
element of criminal history, but consecutive sentences can't be...
More
January 1, 2008
Michael HoskinsAn Allen County judge has publicly expressed his deep regret for failing to control his emotions late last year when he verbally
berated members of a defendant's family following a sentencing hearing.Allen Superior Judge Kenneth R. Scheibenberger filed
a formal answer Aug. 8 to the charges lodged against him July 15 by the Indiana Commission on Judicial Qualifications. The
judicial disciplinary body has charged him with four counts of misconduct for his behavior in a fellow jurist's courtroom
in November.At that...
More
With all due respect, Rick, I think you probably would be making a mistake by going to law school. The job market for attorneys is so saturated, you may well find yourself unemployed and with a lot of debt. You mention law would be a good supplement to your skills. True. But employers unfortunately don't value that. You will find that a law degree may well pigeonhole you into an attorney slot and limit career options. If you have a good job now I would hold onto that. As an attorney, you may well end up making less with the aforementioned debt.
Jack, I was only responding to bill's comment of tying everybody in government together. I agree with you though, it takes one bad apple to ruin the bunch.. As in any profession. What's truly unfair is when somebody violates someone's trust and takes complete advantage of someone
John’s comment is unfair. The majority of attorneys can be trusted. Unfortunately, all it takes is one greedy, unscrupulous, immoral attorney to jade the public.
In regards to bill's comment about trusting the cover meant. We can trust them about as much as we can trust attorneys'.
This is disturbing to learn...