ILNews

Possible end of tax credit leaves future renewable energy sources up in the air

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
Indiana Lawyer Focus

Newton County lawyer Dan Blaney has a blunt reaction to the potential end of a federal subsidy that has enabled the rise of wind energy in his part of the state. “We’re in trouble,” he said.

Blaney has helped Benton County government, landowners and others in northwest Indiana, where the state’s greatest concentration of wind farms has developed with a big impact on the local economy.

blaney Blaney

But lately, most everything has stopped. Not much wind business is stirring in the Morocco office of Blaney & Walton. “Nobody’s broken any ground or done any construction” on wind turbines in northwest Indiana, he said. “Without that incentive, these wind developers and bankers, they don’t want to get involved.”

In Benton and White counties alone, more than 750 towering turbines are in place across thousands of acres, with a capacity to generate more than 1,000 megawatts of electricity, according to the American Wind Energy Association. That’s sufficient to meet the needs of more than 41,600 homes.

But the federal Renewable Electricity Production Tax Credit for wind energy expires Dec. 31. It provides a federal subsidy of 2.2 cents per kilowatt hour generated for 10 years after a wind turbine is in operation. Most turbines are expected to have a lifespan of at least 30 years.

The looming expiration of the tax credit, meanwhile, is producing a whirlwind of activity at the Wildcat Wind Farm under development north of Elwood in rural Madison and Howard counties. E.ON Climate and Renewables is building the farm, and

communications manager Matt Tulis said the pace of construction is stepped up because the company can only claim the tax credit for turbines that are generating electricity by Dec. 31.

“We’re confident we can get it finished in time,” Tulis said. The $400 million project includes 125 turbines generating up to 200 megawatts of electricity.

But E.ON’s bigger designs for the Wildcat farm are on hold. It had proposed construction of three phases extending across thousands of acres into Tipton and Miami counties. “We are interested in doing more phases in that area. We like the wind resource, we like the transmission availability there,” Tulis said. “The production tax credit will definitely have an influence on future phases.”

Bingham Greenebaum Doll LLP partner Mary Solada represents E.ON, and she said without the tax credit, new wind projects are unlikely.

“I think it would decimate the industry,” Solada said. “From everything I’ve heard and read and talked to folks in the industry, the economic model in the industry today assumes the tax credit.”

That model might change in time, but in the current climate, wind power is facing multiple challenges. “It’s kind of like a perfect storm of bad things,” Solada said, listing the expiration of the tax credit, a downturn in manufacturing, and the emergence of inexpensive and abundant natural gas.

“It’s good for consumers, but for people who generate power, it’s not very good,” she said.

Indiana is among the top 15 states in wind power generation, according to the AWEA, and there appears to be bipartisan consensus, at least among some key lawmakers, to extend the credit. Republican Sen. Charles Grassley of Iowa, the No. 3 state for wind power, has urged renewal of the tax credit that was signed into law in 1992 by President Bill Clinton and later renewed by President George W. Bush.

“I expect we’ll probably find out at the eleventh hour whether the federal subsidies expire or continue,” said Bob Clark, a partner in the environmental group at Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP in Indianapolis who has worked on wind energy matters.

Indiana Republican Sen. Dan Coats is the lone Hoosier in Congress seated on an energy committee. Spokeswoman Tara DiJulio said, “This is all being looked at in a larger picture with the fiscal cliff package.

“At this time, when it comes to any extension of the credit, (Coats) believes we need to be looking at it as part of reforming the overall tax code,” DiJulio said. “The senator is supportive of alternative and renewable energy, but they must prove themselves to be competitive on their own merits without perpetual federal subsidies.”

solada Solada

Kent Frandsen, an attorney with Parr Richey Obremskey Frandsen & Patterson in Indianapolis, has helped negotiate on behalf of landowners where wind farms were built. He said the expiration of a subsidy was a “theoretical concern” that wouldn’t impact existing farms.

Still, he said the rise of wind power carries complications that should be addressed in leases, and landowners are best served by having numbers on their side to negotiate the best deal and get terms in writing. It also is to the benefit of developers, since they’d prefer not to deal with dozens of leases each with differing terms.

“There are issues that come up that you have to deal with, what you might call after-effects,” Frandsen said. Those range from the impacts of turbines on farming operations to the heavy cranes used to raise the turbines that can crack subterranean drainage tiles.

In the land leases he’s drafted for a group of about 40 landowners in Benton County, he’s tried to address those and other theoretical concerns.

“What happens if the wind company goes out of business 10 or 20 years from now?” he said. “If the government doesn’t continue to subsidize these companies, it seems to me there’s a risk some of these companies will fail, and who will be there to remove them and the six feet of concrete put in the ground to support these turbines?”

To address such concerns, the plant developer agreed with landowners to put money in escrow in case the turbines needed to be removed at a later date, Frandsen said.

Wind energy detractors point to the high cost of turbines, their limited capacity to operate in high winds, and the uneven ability to store or transmit the power they generate. Critics say the subsidy makes the cost of a kilowatt hour of electricity produced by wind generation far more expensive than traditional fossil-fuel electricity generation.

But Blaney, from his vantage point in the small town of Morocco, sees it differently.

“Here’s what it means,” Blaney said. “Each wind tower provides the farmer from $5,000 to $10,000 and up per year.” Some landowners have as many as 27 turbines operating, and their footprint doesn’t remove much acreage from production. “In farming, when times are tough, that would mean the family farm.”

County governments will reap millions in property taxes, even after tax abatements, he said. Steelworkers in Lake County and ancillary businesses around the state benefit and create jobs, he said. “It provides employment in these rural counties, not a large number, but probably 30 to 40 employees in Benton County work in the wind industry.”

Blaney said his understanding is that the federal subsidy covers about 30 percent of the big up-front investment in wind power. That’s not unlike the government aid that other energy sources and infrastructure received at their inception, he said.

He hopes the winds shift again and conditions are favorable to further development of a clean, renewable source of energy. Lately, though, the only such work has been a few agreements with landowners to provide leases if future development occurs.

“I don’t believe the wind industry can be developed without the intervention of the federal government,” Blaney said.•
 

ADVERTISEMENT

Post a comment to this story

COMMENTS POLICY
We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
 
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
 
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in Indiana Lawyer editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
 
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
 
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
 

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Indiana State Bar Association

Indianapolis Bar Association

Evansville Bar Association

Allen County Bar Association

Indiana Lawyer on Facebook

facebook
ADVERTISEMENT
Subscribe to Indiana Lawyer
  1. I can understand a 10 yr suspension for drinking and driving and not following the rules,but don't you think the people who compleate their sentences and are trying to be good people of their community,and are on the right path should be able to obtain a drivers license to do as they please.We as a state should encourage good behavior instead of saying well you did all your time but we can't give you a license come on.When is a persons time served than cause from where I'm standing,its still a punishment,when u can't have the freedom to go where ever you want to in car,truck ,motorcycle,maybe their should be better programs for people instead of just throwing them away like daily trash,then expecting them to change because they we in jail or prison for x amount of yrs.Everyone should look around because we all pay each others bills,and keep each other in business..better knowledge equals better community equals better people...just my 2 cents

  2. I was wondering about the 6 million put aside for common attorney fees?does that mean that if you are a plaintiff your attorney fees will be partially covered?

  3. I expressed my thought in the title, long as it was. I am shocked that there is ever immunity from accountability for ANY Government agency. That appears to violate every principle in the US Constitution, which exists to limit Government power and to ensure Government accountability. I don't know how many cases of legitimate child abuse exist, but in the few cases in which I knew the people involved, in every example an anonymous caller used DCS as their personal weapon to strike at innocent people over trivial disagreements that had no connection with any facts. Given that the system is vulnerable to abuse, and given the extreme harm any action by DCS causes to families, I would assume any degree of failure to comply with the smallest infraction of personal rights would result in mandatory review. Even one day of parent-child separation in the absence of reasonable cause for a felony arrest should result in severe penalties to those involved in the action. It appears to me, that like all bureaucracies, DCS is prone to interpret every case as legitimate. This is not an accusation against DCS. It is a statement about the nature of bureaucracies, and the need for ADDED scrutiny of all bureaucratic actions. Frankly, I question the constitutionality of bureaucracies in general, because their power is delegated, and therefore unaccountable. No Government action can be unaccountable if we want to avoid its eventual degeneration into irrelevance and lawlessness, and the law of the jungle. Our Constitution is the source of all Government power, and it is the contract that legitimizes all Government power. To the extent that its various protections against intrusion are set aside, so is the power afforded by that contract. Eventually overstepping the limits of power eliminates that power, as a law of nature. Even total tyranny eventually crumbles to nothing.

  4. Being dedicated to a genre keeps it alive until the masses catch up to the "trend." Kent and Bill are keepin' it LIVE!! Thank you gentlemen..you know your JAZZ.

  5. Hemp has very little THC which is needed to kill cancer cells! Growing cannabis plants for THC inside a hemp field will not work...where is the fear? From not really knowing about Cannabis and Hemp or just not listening to the people teaching you through testimonies and packets of info over the last few years! Wake up Hoosier law makers!

ADVERTISEMENT