Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowThe Indiana Supreme Court on Tuesday issued an order that allows Chris Garten, who Senate Republicans had planned to install as the chamber’s leader on Tuesday afternoon, to be sworn in and seated as the state senator for District 45.
The order comes just hours after Garten asked the court to clear the way for him to be sworn in for a third time.
The Supreme Court ordered the Clark Circuit Court to remove the portion of its temporary restraining order that prohibited Garten from taking the oath of office or being seated in the Senate.
The Senate is scheduled to convene at 1:30 to swear members in and elect its leadership.
The Supreme Court, however, did not lift the provision preventing the Clark County Election Board and clerk from certifying the Nov. 3 election results. The order also does not stop proceedings in Clark Circuit Court, where a preliminary injunction hearing is scheduled for Nov. 18.
In its order, the court cited Article 4, Section 10 of the Indiana Constitution, which states that the respective houses of the Legislature are the sole judges of the results of the elections of their members.
Garten, an incumbent, declared victory in the race in Senate District 45 — which includes all of Clark County and a portion of Floyd County — after vote totals showed him besting challenger Nick Marshall by 297 votes, or about two-thirds of a percentage point.
Democrat are seeking a recount in the race and asked the court to stop Garten from taking office before that’s completed. On Monday, Scott County Circuit Judge Jason Mount ruled that Garten is temporarily prohibited “from presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45.”
On Tuesday morning, Garten filed a petition with the Indiana Supreme Court arguing that Mount exceeded his constitutional authority by blocking certification of the election results and preventing Garten from taking his seat in the Indiana Senate.
In a closed-door caucus meeting in August, majority Republicans in the Senate chose Garten to serve as the chamber’s next leader, replacing Sen. Rod Bray, a Martinsville Republican who stepped down from the position. That decision was to have been formalized with a vote on Tuesday when the Senate met for the Legislature’s Organization Day for the 2027 session.
The Scott Couty order would prevent that. A court hearing on the request from Democrats for a preliminary injunction is set for Wednesday afternoon in Jeffersonville.
The restraining order sought by the Clark County Democratic chairman argued that voting equipment problems on Election Day in Jeffersonville leave questions about the accuracy of the reported election results.
The tallies showed Garten had 21,817 votes to 21,520 for Marshall.
Democrats maintain the Clark County Election Board — controlled 2-1 by Republicans — failed to adequately review problems involving four precincts that voted at Jeffersonville High School, where a ballot scanner malfunction was reported on Election Day.
The court filing said time is needed to “resolve the discrepancies in the poll pad records or determine whether all of the votes cast at Jeffersonville High School were counted through the transition from one machine to another: the machine’s results tape reports 1,640 ballots; 474 ballots were cast before the machine was replaced, but only 333 voters had signed in by 11:08 a.m.; and the poll pad records show more than 100 voters signing in after 7:00 p.m., an hour after the polls closed.”
Republican Clark County Clerk Ryan Lynch, a county election board member, did not immediately reply Monday to an email seeking comment on the court filing.
Mount, a Democrat, was assigned as the special judge after a Clark County judge’s recusal from the case, according to court records. Mount is the brother of Republican U.S. Rep. Erin Houchin, who served in the state Senate with Garten.
The judge’s order also blocks the Clark County Election Board from certifying the election results until he decides whether to grant an injunction.
Democrats have said they intend to seek a recount of the Senate race results. Candidates have until Tuesday to file recount petitions, with county party chairs having until Friday to do so.
Clark County Democratic Chair Miguel Hampton, state Democratic Chair Karen Tallian and Ninth Congressional District party Chair Adam Dickey said in a joint statement that the “Clark County Election Board left us with no other option but to resolve this issue in the courts.”
“The voters deserve to have their ballots counted fairly and accurately, and we cannot just look the other way and not worry about what happened or whether the results are even legitimate,” they said. “The fact that this election affects one of the most powerful Republicans in state government makes this situation unique.”
Indiana Capital Chronicle is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Indiana Capital Chronicle maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Niki Kelly for questions.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.