Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowA Marion Superior Court judge has denied secretary of state candidate Greg Ballard’s motion to compel the Indiana Election Commission to meet soon to consider campaign finance complaints in the tightly contested race.
Judge Jennifer Prinz Harrison said in an order filed Monday that Ballard in urging that the commission meet before Election Day offers only speculation that such a meeting might affect voter opinions and decision making. The judge noted that the commission scheduled a Nov. 20 public meeting, and Ballard provides no evidence that the scheduled meeting is not sufficient to address the complaints.
Ballard had filed a lawsuit against the commission, asking a court to order it to meet to consider four complaints. He also filed a motion for a preliminary injunction last week in the case.
Ballard has said the commission has not met since July and is ignoring the complaints to protect the main political parties in the race. He wants a meeting held before Election Day on Nov. 3 so voters could consider any results that came from it. Ballard said he wasn’t asking for a particular outcome, he just wanted the commission to review the complaints.
Ballard, who is running under the newly formed Lincoln Party banner, said Monday in a statement that his campaign is exploring its legal options to compel the commission to meet.
“Might makes right,” Ballard said. “The laws are intended to protect those in power. Not so long ago, the Election Commission acted in a more ethical, nonpartisan manner.
“However, the law does not protect voters from blatant political maneuvering if the commission decides to act to protect political parties over people. “
Ballard wanted the commission to consider complaints that focus on Republican candidate Max Engling and Democrat Beau Bayh.
Libertarian Lauri Shillings also is running for secretary of state.
The office of state Attorney General Todd Rokita argued in a response to Ballard’s motion that he has no standing to ask for that relief.
Rokita’s office noted in court papers filed Thursday that Ballard did not file the complaints or have any involvement in them and has not shown how he will be personally harmed by the lack of a meeting.
Rokita’s office also noted that “it is not conceivable that the Commission could meet, conduct an investigation, and issue a decision within the remaining two weeks before the election.”
“Accordingly, there is zero chance that Plaintiff will suffer harm without a preliminary injunction,” the office said in a response to Ballard’s motion.
Ballard, a former Republican mayor of Indianapolis, started the litigation representing himself. He announced last week that he added Greenwood attorney Michelle Harter, who specializes in election law, to represent him.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.