Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowIncorrect jury instructions have prompted the Indiana Supreme Court to vacate a felony neglect conviction that resulted in a 40-year sentence for a child’s death.
The state high court said Monday that Matthew Dirig should receive a new trial with correct instructions.
A Huntington Circuit Court jury had convicted Dirig in 2024 of Level 1 felony neglect of a dependent resulting in death for the 2022 death of his girlfriend’s 8-year-old son.
The child, who had behavioral and emotional issues, committed suicide by tightening a zip tie around his neck after Dirig had locked him in his bedroom alone, according to the Supreme Court’s opinion. The child had been prone to emotional outbursts and had previously threatened to kill himself.
Dirig’s girlfriend returned home to find her boyfriend playing video games and then checked on her child, whom she found unresponsive, the opinion states. Dirig later told police that he used zip ties for work, and he had previously given the child some to play with.
Dirig was sentenced to 38 years in prison followed by two years suspended to probation.
He appealed on several grounds, including arguing that the court made an error by giving the jury broader instructions than what were required for the law.
The Indiana Court of Appeals agreed that the instructions were incorrect, but it also concluded that another instruction fixed the error.
The Supreme Court noted that the law requires prosecutors to prove that Dirig knowingly or intentionally endangered the child. Jury instructions at his trial explained that, but two other instructions also told the jury to consider what a reasonable caregiver would have done.
The justices concluded that was a fundamental error.
“The trial court initially instructed the jury correctly, explaining that it should apply a ‘knowing’ culpability standard,” stated the opinion, written by Justice Derek Molter. “But then the court mistakenly watered down that standard by instructing the jury to consider whether Dirig acted as a reasonable caregiver would, which is instead a lower, negligence standard.”
That helped prosecutors and not Dirig, the court noted.
Justice Jeffrey Slaughter wrote in a dissenting opinion that while the jury received improper instructions, correct ones mitigated the potential for confusing jurors.
“Our only role is to assess whether the jury-instruction errors of which Dirig now complains deprived him of a fair trial,” Slaughter wrote. “Unlike the Court, I conclude they did not.”
The case is Matthew Joseph Dirig v. State of Indiana, No. 26S-CR-399.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.