A Grant County woman who reported her 10-year-old stepdaughter missing last weekend was arrested Wednesday in the girl’s death after her body was found hidden inside a plastic trash bag in a shed behind their home.
Amanda D. Carmack, 34, was arrested after investigators found Skylea Carmack’s body at around 3 a.m. Wednesday, state police said. Carmack, who lives in Gas City, about 80 miles northeast of Indianapolis, was being held on preliminary charges of murder, neglect, strangulation and domestic battery, according to the state police and online records.
Formal charges are expected to be filed later this week against Carmack, the Grant County Prosecutor’s Office said. Online records did not list an attorney who could comment on her behalf.
Preliminary evidence indicated Skylea was fatally strangled Saturday, the same day her stepmother reported her missing, investigators said. An autopsy will determine the cause of death.
Skylea’s body wasn’t found during a Sunday search of the property, including the shed, State Police Sgt. Tony Slocum said. At the time, investigators were looking for a living child, but evidence led them back to the property, he said.
“The shed was searched initially but she was in a trash bag and you can imagine if you’re looking for a person you’re not looking for a little trash bag,” he said. “At that point they had no indication that something nefarious had happened to her.”
Slocum said investigators believe Carmack acted alone. He said she reported her stepdaughter missing Saturday, but investigators believe the girl was already dead when that call was placed.
In her call reporting Skylea missing, Carmack said the child may have run away from home and that she had done so previously, Slocum said.
The girl’s father, Kevin Carmack, had told WXIN-TV that Skylea had been home with her stepmother and six other children when she went missing.
The six other children who were in the home are now in the care of the Department of Child Services.