Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowA nonprofit trade association tied to social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok is challenging Indiana’s new law that imposes certain age-verification and parental-consent restrictions on social media providers.
The lawsuit claims Indiana House Enrolled Act 1408, which will take effect on Jan. 1, violates the First Amendment by restricting users’ access to constitutionally protected speech and forcing platforms to hand over editorial control.
HEA 1408 was signed into law in March and puts certain requirements on social media platforms accessible to adolescents. The law requires social media platforms to get parental consent before an adolescent creates an account on the platform, request age-verification details on users and restrict certain content curation features on adolescents’ accounts.
The original act was introduced alongside other legislation created in response to the disappearance and death of Fishers teenager Hailey Buzbee, who disappeared in January 2026 after meeting an adult man online.
Plaintiff NetChoice argues the law is not narrowly tailored to meet state interest and burdens more speech than necessary. In particular, NetChoice argues the law violates the First Amendment rights of minors under age 16 whose parents believe social media is harmless or even good for children.
The organization says that less restrictive alternatives are available to the state, such as existing tools that allow parents to monitor their child’s social media use and a state law that criminalizes inappropriate communication with children.
The lawsuit names the Indiana Office of the Attorney General as the defendant. When asked for a response, Attorney General Todd Rokita’s office said NetChoice has a “long track record” of suing states that pass laws to hold their members responsible for features used to attract children.
“HEA 1408 is part of Indiana’s effort to address the dangers addictive social media features that go after children,” a spokesperson for the office told The Indiana Lawyer. “As we always do; we will continuously, vigorously, and successfully defend the law against this challenge.”
In May, the attorney general’s office sued two social media companies, Roblox and Discord, believed to be used by the man accused of luring 17-year-old Buzbee from her home. That lawsuit is still pending in Marion County.
NetChoice is seeking a permanent injunction enjoining the state from enforcing the law and a declaration that the law violates the U.S. Constitution.
The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana. The case is NetChoice v. Todd Rokita, in his official capacity as Attorney General of the State of Indiana, 1:26-cv-02500-JRS-TAB.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.