Indiana sheriffs don’t show much appetite for ICE agreements

  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Only eight Indiana sheriff’s departments have signed agreements with the federal government giving them limited immigration enforcement powers even though Attorney General Todd Rokita has pushed the deals.

Rokita said in September that his office planned to work more closely with U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, under a 287(g) agreement that gives his investigators training and the ability to perform some immigration enforcement. He urged sheriffs to follow his lead.

“Every county sheriff across the state should be — and can be — doing what we’re doing. And what sheriffs across the nation are doing,” he said in a press release, adding that working with federal law enforcement is “a key part of how we deport illegal aliens under the FAIRNESS Act.”

IL graphic

While some sheriffs’ departments, like the attorney general’s office, see the agreements as an extra step toward public safety, others worry the agreements will strain their department’s limited resources and sow distrust in law enforcement.

And the total sheriff’s offices involved in these agreements may soon shrink, thanks partly to election results from earlier this month.

To date, just Jasper, Noble, Hamilton, Blackford, Rush, Ripley, Dearborn and Spencer counties have 287(g) agreements with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement that deputize local officers to perform some duties associated with ICE agents, including serving warrants, field enforcement and jail service.

What are these agreements?

The program is named after Section 287(g) of the Immigration and Nationalization Act. Under it, law enforcement officials can receive limited federal immigration enforcement powers.

The program expanded after President Trump issued a sweeping executive order called “Protecting the American People Against Invasion” on Jan. 20, 2025, his first day in office for his second term.

In addition to revoking orders by the previous administration and replacing them with a mandate to execute immigration laws against all noncitizens in the country illegally, the order also allows ICE to deputize state and local law enforcement to perform ICE-related duties.

The agency says it has signed 2,774 agreements with law enforcement agencies as of Nov. 12.

The 287(g) agreements are divided into models including task force, jail enforcement and warrant service.

Under the jail enforcement model, local law enforcement identify and process people in the country illegally who have criminal charges and are removable under federal law, according to ICE. The task force model allows officers to enforce immigration laws while doing routine field work.

Warrant service allows local law enforcement to serve and execute administrative immigration warrants for individuals in their custody.

The Hamilton County Sheriff’s Department was among the first departments to sign a 287(g) agreement, when it entered a jail enforcement model in March 2025. The department later entered the warrant service and task force models last September.

Amy Summerfield (IL file photo)

Amy Summerfield, legal adviser for the sheriff’s department, said the deals were about “being a community partner and keeping Hamilton County safe.”

However, Hamilton County Sheriff-elect Charles Hollowell has told The Indianapolis Star he plans to end the deals.

“We want to make sure our resources are available and put to use locally,” Hollowell told The Star. “We want to maximize deputies assigned to things like patrols and different types of investigations targeting illegal drugs. We also have to worry about traffic safety in our growing community.”

Hollowell did not respond to several request for comment from The Indiana Lawyer.

Noble County Sheriff Max Weber’s department entered a 287(g) agreement in March 2025. He said the deals are key to fighting illegal immigration, which he likened to a home invasion.

Weber said he has about six officers who have been trained to operate within the warrant service model.

Max Weber (IL file photo)

“If they want to come here to the United States legally, come knock on the door … file your paperwork,” Weber said. “But if you’re illegal, it’s just another law you’re breaking. If you give one inch, you’re gonna take a foot. That’s one of the reasons we’re out here helping them (federal immigration enforcement).”

Areas of concern

Blake Lanning, chief deputy for the attorney general’s office, said he blames low participation in the agreements on misinformation from the Indiana Sheriffs’ Association about possible legal liabilities.

He said sheriffs have been found liable in other jurisdictions in “one or two cases” for honoring detainers or holding someone in custody for longer than they normally would be held.

“Those cases are aberrations,” Lanning said. “Indiana in the past two years has issued over 6,100 detainers to county jails, and over 98% of those detainers have been honored.

Blake Lanning (IL file photo)

“None of those cases resulted in a lawsuit or any sheriff being held liable.”

Sheriffs’ Association President Steve Luce said Lanning’s comments are perplexing. He added that both organizations have had cordial relations for a long time.

“We have no rub with the attorney general’s office. Period. At all,” he said. “You know, we will always continue to have an open door, talk to them about any other future legislation. But in the end … I take that information, and I present it to the sheriffs. Then they can decide, because it’s their office, how they want to move forward.”

The Indiana Lawyer reached out to several sheriffs’ departments to discuss the agreements but only a couple responded.

Vanderburgh County Sheriff Noah Robinson said his department doesn’t have the manpower or resources to participate in a 287(g) agreement.

“Signing one would deputize my officers to do a federal agency’s work, and I need every one of them focused on local public safety here in Vanderburgh County,” he said. “I am currently 18 deputies short of my authorized strength of 119.”

Steve Luce (IL file photo)

He added that property tax relief “has kneecapped local governments, forcing cuts to my 2027 budget and making significant pay raises impossible.”

Lanning said the agreements require very little effort from sheriffs’ departments, and they come with some financial incentives that could help departments.

Push to cooperate meets resistance

Although 287(g) agreements are voluntary, Georgia and Florida’s legislatures have considered mandating them.

In Indiana, cooperation with immigration enforcement has become a touchy subject.

On March 5, Gov. Mike Braun signed the FAIRNESS Act into law. It does not mandate that law enforcement agencies sign these agreements, but it does require their cooperation with immigration officials.

Noah Robinson (IL file photo)

The law says governmental bodies and postsecondary educational institutions may not restrict federal immigration enforcement to less than the full extent allowed by law, provided it doesn’t violate existing federal or state laws.

In April, Monroe County Sheriff Ruben Marté sued Rokita in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, arguing the FAIRNESS ACT is unconstitutional.

In his complaint, Marté argued that detaining people upon ICE’s request without a warrant or probable cause would violate their Fourth Amendment rights.

“Sheriff Marté cannot order his officers to comply … without violating his oath to protect and uphold the Constitution and exposing the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office (“MCSO”) to significant civil liability from suits by individuals whose rights would be violated by the unlawful detentions,” Marté’s lawsuit reads.

Rokita told The Indiana Lawyer that the law was on his side. He wasn’t going to allow any Indiana county to become “a safe haven for illegal immigration.”

The fear factor

Lanning said immigration is a problem in Indiana. He says he blames former President Joe Biden’s administration for allowing millions of people to enter the U.S. illegally.

“That is why the attorney general has long been saying that because of the Biden border crisis, every state is a border state. That’s very true of Indiana, too,” Lanning said.

But organizations like the Immigrant Legal Resource Center are concerned that the agreements will encourage officers to engage in racial profiling and stoke fear in the community. The center said in its 2026 report that the task force model of the agreements is the broadest one available and can “provide carte blanche for rampant racial profiling.”

Robinson, the Vanderburgh County sheriff, said he worried that these agreements would scare some residents and wind up doing more harm than good.

“I want every resident to call 911 when they need help. Every resident, regardless of their immigration status,” he said in an email. “I DO NOT want a spouse scared to report domestic violence because someone in their home is not a legal resident.”•

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Get full access to The Indiana Lawyer! Subscribe Now

Get full access to The Indiana Lawyer! Subscribe Now

Get full access to The Indiana Lawyer! Upgrade Now

Get full access to The Indiana Lawyer! Upgrade Now

Get full access to The Indiana Lawyer!

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In