Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowLast month, New York City-based law firm Weil Gotshal & Manges set the legal world abuzz when it announced plans to wind down operations, signaling the end of a century-old firm that last year brought in nearly $1.2 billion in revenue, according to The Wall Street Journal.
That became necessary in part because several partners at the firm who accounted for large portions of Weil’s revenue took offers elsewhere, a move the Journal called “virtually unheard of” for a firm of its size (about 1,200 attorneys worldwide).
Back in August, several Weil attorneys known as rainmakers, or partners who bring in significant business to a firm, announced their decisions to leave the firm to pursue other opportunities.
While firm leaders in Indianapolis aren’t facing that dilemma, the news draws attention to how local firms retain top attorneys. Through initiatives like partner class systems and maintaining a core set of values across the firm, local leaders say they are seeing partners stay and thrive at their jobs.

Robert Hicks, chief executive officer of Taft Stettinius & Hollister, said the firm considers all variations of factors to maintain stability. Taft, which was founded in the late 1800s in Ohio, is now the second largest law firm in Indianapolis, according to Indianapolis Business Journal research. The firm staffs nearly 200 lawyers locally and 1,300 around the United States.
“Our diversification from an economic perspective, a geographical perspective, and also from a leadership perspective, really makes us have a much stronger stability than maybe some of the high-end Wall Street firms,” said Hicks, who is based in the firm’s Indianapolis office.
Partner priorities
Leaders at Taft have implemented several strategies including rainmaker distribution and a one-class partner system to keep partners and associates content, Hicks said.
In a two-class partner system, law firms separate partners by income/nonequity and equity partner levels. Equity partners traditionally earn both a base compensation and a share of the firm’s profits in addition to having a vote in major committees for things like compensation, Hicks said. Nonequity partners have a higher base compensation compared with associates but do not share profits in the firm or serve on the major committees.
At Taft, all firm partners have the same share in profits and are eligible to be on firm committees, Hicks said.
Meanwhile, rainmaker distribution ensures that no partner is earning a disproportionate share of the firm’s revenue.
Taft shifted to the one-class system in 2018 in response to feedback from partners who found it difficult to achieve higher status in a multi-tier system. Some of these partners were trying to balance a legal career with supporting a family and couldn’t see themselves making equity partner, Hicks said.
“Especially the young women would look around, and they’d see an older white male population in the equity partner ranks, all of whom were rainmakers, and they would look around and say, ‘I don’t see being part of that club,’” Hicks said. “We would lose those people. They wouldn’t just leave Taft.They would leave the law profession.”

Taft’s decision to change its partner system is a move Hicks said aligns with the firm’s mission to be a modern law firm. Around 70% of Taft’s leadership positions are occupied by women and ethnically diverse people, Hicks said. And while the firm assesses potential partners based on merit, Taft wants to ensure that the firm reflects the attorneys coming up through the ranks.
“You need to change your governance and your partnership makeup and your committee structures to reflect modern demographics and reality,” Hicks said.
The shift in the firm’s partner system has proven successful so far: Since implementing the new system, Taft’s attrition level has dropped from 8% to 3%, meaning more attorneys are staying at the firm, Hicks said.
Taft also distributes its wealth to keep the firm from losing its footing. According to Hicks, Taft’s largest rainmaker only pulls in about 1.5% of the firm’s gross revenue, a strategic move the firm makes to avoid giving too much power to a few individuals.
If a rainmaker making a high percentage is unhappy and leaves, money and clients go with them, shaking the structure of the firm, Hicks said.
During his tenure at Taft so far, no partner has walked away from the firm, but even if one did, the firm wouldn’t chase after them offering more money, Hicks said. If the firm did, it would undo the work leaders have put in to give their attorneys equal opportunity to rise in the ranks.
“We try and do things programmatically so that everybody’s subject to the same rules,” Hicks said. “If I start cutting special deals with people, all of a sudden we’re not subject to the same rules, and now you’re breaking down the culture of the firm.”
Maintaining culture
Law firms The Indiana Lawyer spoke with emphasized culture as a sticking point for retaining partners and attorneys at other levels.

Alex Macdonald, chief strategy officer at Carmel-based McCarter & English, keeps a sign in his office that reads “culture eats strategy for breakfast.” It’s a reminder to keep the firm’s morals and values at the forefront of everything the firm does.
McCarter & English does so by prioritizing community-building experiences like staff retreats to maintain a sense of camaraderie among attorneys. The firm is also willing to turn away certain business opportunities if they don’t align with the firm’s values.
“If it doesn’t fit who we are, it won’t fit what we want to do,” Macdonald said.
The commitment has been successful so far, with the firm retaining 86% of its lateral partners over the last several years, Macdonald said.
McCarter & English’s culture strategy prioritizes growth, continuity and the firm’s brand. A supportive environment for attorneys comes first, Macdonald said. When attorneys feel supported to grow, they’re more likely to serve clients well.
One way McCarter & English maintains a strong sense of culture among attorneys is through its pro bono work. The firm allows attorneys to pursue unlimited pro bono opportunities, which gives them the chance to learn new skills and explore other interests within their legal practices, said Amy Fisher, office managing partner at McCarter & English.
The experience is particularly beneficial for younger attorneys who wouldn’t otherwise be able to develop these new skills, Macdonald said.

The desire by McCarter attorneys to pursue pro bono opportunities is a reflection of the larger culture the firm maintains, she added.
“You’re not just in it for the economics,” she said. You’re actually giving back.”
Some partnership movement does happen in the Indianapolis market. Fisher and fellow office managing partner Katherine Althoff joined McCarter & English and helped open the firm’s first Indiana-based office in 2022 in part due to the culture they knew they would find at the firm, which is based out of New Jersey.
Originally partners in Ice Miller’s litigation practice, the women saw a new opportunity, and culture, at McCarter. Several Ice Miller and McCarter attorneys worked on mutual-client cases together, and the collaboration blossomed into a desire to continue working together, Fisher said.
“At times the work itself can be very fun and exciting, particularly in litigation,” Fisher said. “But it’s the people. It’s always been the people from day one, and so, when you’re working with people on a daily basis, and those people are at a different firm, it was just sort of a natural progression for us to leave Ice Miller and go to McCarter.”

Brian Garrison, partner and leader of Faegre Drinker’s Indianapolis office, said attorneys at the firm look for meaningful relationships, support and opportunity for growth as leading factors to ensure their ability to thrive at a law firm. He often hears from attorneys who join the firm that Faegre Drinker’s culture feels different from other places they’ve been.
“A big part of that is the personal relationships that we have with each other that create that sense of connection that carries over into how we work together, how we support each other, both on client matters and otherwise, and then that impacts how we serve clients,” he said.
Garrison said that while some think growth at a firm only applies to younger associates, it’s important for partners too. Although more experienced in their careers, leaders at Faegre prioritize connecting partners with resources and subject-matter expertise on both the legal and operational side to help partners build a more sophisticated practice that helps them better serve clients.
Planning for the future
Law firm leaders emphasize that keeping partners happy extends beyond a firm’s top leaders. It trickles down to how young associates, who are often the future of the firm, are served early on in their careers.
Ice Miller is investing in its future partners through a firmwide retreat this fall, chief managing partner Josh Christie told The Lawyer. The firm is also building on ways to enhance its use of artificial intelligence to progress the firm, and its staff, into the future.
“We want our lawyers to see a future for themselves at Ice Miller and to feel confident about the future of the firm, both here in Indianapolis and across all of our markets,” Christie said in an email.

support and opportunity for growth as leading factors to ensure their ability to thrive at a law firm. (The Indiana Lawyer photo|Chad Williams)
Faegre’s Garrison said his firm prioritizes social interaction, community involvement and business development to give attorneys the opportunity to grow within the firm.
“There’s a variety of those events that we’ll do and programming that we do for our lawyers that we try to tailor to their needs at every level, so they’re feeling not only engaged, but supported by the firm in what they need to do to continue to progress their career in the way they want to,” Garrison said.
Since 2021, Taft has implemented a professional development program, which helps associates build their law careers at the firm. The professional development team has nine people, all former attorneys and associate law school deans, whose jobs are to help young associates develop skills, solve problems and act as a liaison between them and firm partners, Hicks said.
The program is important because building and maintaining a strong law firm can’t just serve the firm’s most experienced attorneys, Hicks said. It’s important to bring young associates to the table as well.
Taft will continue to evolve to serve both its top attorneys and those climbing the ranks, according to Hicks.
“I may be the CEO of Taft, but I work for 2,300 people because they all have two legs and they can go anywhere they want,” he said.•
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.